Jimmy Stewart has lived his entire life in the small town of Bedford Falls, New
York. As a child his main goal in life was to escape the town and explore
the world. That never happened. Life and Fate prevented his ever
leaving, but maybe that wasn't so bad because he ended up marrying the beautiful
Donna Reed, having some cute children and giving the townsfolk a banking
alternative to the wicked Lionel Barrymore who is a slumlord and runs the towns
biggest bank. (I always get a kick out of seeing Lionel play an evil character,
since, in my mind, I always see him as Kringelein from
GRAND HOTEL.) Things are actually going pretty good for Stewart...all the way up
until Christmas Eve, 1945. That's when Stewart's banking partner, Thomas
Mitchell, makes a foolish mistake which could destroy Stewart's life and pretty
much the hopes of the entire town. Stewart is beside himself with fear and
decides to throw himself into the river to make it look like an accidental
drowning. That way his family could cash in on his life insurance.
But then, right as he's about to jump, some blinking star creatures send an
angel down to talk some sense into him and show him what life would be like if
he had never been born.
IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE is a wonderful film with great acting from an impressive
cast. It also looks really nice, but one of the things that always
bothered me is when Stewart turned down his childhood friends offer of investing
in plastics. His friend ends up filthy rich and Stewart ends up literally
one mistake away from suicide! I felt that twist in the story was
unneeded. Another thing that bothered me: the last act went
completely over the top with the unrealistic sentimentality. And
Lionel Barrymore never got any punishment for being a total asshole for decades
or for stealing the other banks money! And while the "never been
born" part was very entertaining, it was (for somebody like myself who cannot
see that my being alive is beneficial to anybody) kinda depressing.
If an angel-in-training was ever sent to talk me out of suicide with this "never
been born" bullshit, he'd probably slit my throat and walk home defeated and
wingless.
That said, IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE is still required viewing for anybody who loves
Cinema...mainly because of the acting. Also (for anybody keeping score), I
fully believe that
THE BEST YEARS OF OUR LIVES
was the correct choice for Best Picture of the Year. It's simply a
better film than IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE.