I've long had a fascination with dance marathons, not the bullshit 12-24 hour
ones they have nowadays for charity, but the Depression-era dance marathons
where they would pretty much just torture the contestants for days, weeks and
sometimes even months!!! And it wasn't just dancing, but also
speed-walking, eating while standing up, figure-eight races, blindfolded racing,
heel-to-toe sprints, "cot nights", racing while tied together and so on.
THEY SHOOT HORSES, DON'T THEY? is about one such dance marathon. Our
penniless heroes, Jane Fonda and Michael Sarrazin, enter a marathon dance
contest with a prize of $1,500. Things go smoothly for the first
600 hours or so, but then the lack of sleep, mental/physical exhaustion
and the roar of the blood-thirsty crowds really start to take its toll.
Still these desperate people fight on. How long can it possible go?
A dark subject matter like this would have been perfect for directors
like Polanski or Kubrick (can you imagine the intensity of the end game in a
dance marathon film by Kubrick?!), but that didn't happen, so instead of a
masterpiece about dehumanization and a social commentary with some black humor
mixed in, we get an alright but overall forgettable film that honestly was kinda
boring. The speed-walking scenes were engaging, but other than that I
really wasn't into it. None of the characters were successfully fleshed
out, the flash forwards were distracting and unneeded, the pacing was a drag,
the sets and costumes looked just like that, the continuity of the contest
didn't come off very well and that ending. Lame.
It might sound like I disliked the film, but that's not true. It just
didn't click with me. I'm sure there's tons of people out there that love
this film (hell, it had 9 Oscar nominations and even won 1). I'm just not
one of them.