Adapted from Dashiell Hammett's "The Farewell Murder", this third THIN MAN is my
second favorite of the series. Nick and Nora are back in New York and upon their
arrival they are urgently summoned to the Long Island estate of Colonel MacFay (who is the
caretaker of Nora's family fortune). They find MacFay in a frantic state.
It seems that an engineer that used to work for him was sent to prison for 10 years
for some bullshit and he blames MacFay. There have been various threats and acts
of violence and now MacFay is in fear of his life. Long story short, MacFay ends
up getting murdered later that night in his own bed (good job protecting him, Nick!!!) and the obvious suspect is the disgruntled ex-employee, but is he the
real killer?
This film is a lot of fun. The mystery is intriguing and this is probably the
funniest of all of the THIN MAN films. I especially liked that Nora forced
herself more into the investigation, but Nick was always one step ahead of her.
Their playful banter back and forth was really cute, especially when they went
to the boarding house and Nick used Nora as an unwilling cover. Very funny.
Another positive is the return of Nat Pendleton and, of course, Asta! Also, this is
where the Charles' welcome little baby Nickie, but I couldn't give a fuck about that little bastard. Luckily he doesn't distract from the story and isn't onscreen
much. Sexy Virginia Grey on the other hand should have been onscreen more!
Part 1 - The Thin Man (1934)
Part 2 - After the Thin Man (1936)
Part 4 - Shadow of the Thin Man (1941)
Part 5 - The Thin Man Goes Home (1945)
Part 6 - Song of the Thin Man (1947)